Essays on American politics and foreign policy

By Donald E. Nuechterlein

Donald Nuechterlein is a political scientist and writer who resides near Charlottesville, Virginia. He is the author of numerous books on American politics and foreign policy, including

  • Defiant Superpower: The New American Hegemony, 2005
  • America Recommitted: A Superpower Assesses its Role in a Turbulent World, 2000
  • A Cold War Odyssey, 1997


Donald Nuechterlein



Fifty-one years ago Americans were asking whether President Lyndon Johnson could be reelected in 1968. The escalating Vietnam War triggered major demonstrations at college campuses and in Washington, and Democrats began questioning Johnson's foreign policy leadership. In 2019 the political climate is less severe, but Donald Trump causes anxiety even among Republicans about his leadership, especially the escalating trade war with China and potential shooting war with Iran.

A new book, "The Men and the Moment: The Election of 1968," traces the campaigns of eight serious contenders for president fifty years ago. Four were Democrats, three Republicans, and one formed his own party. The book's author, historian Aram Goudsouzian, writes in his introduction: "The echoes of 1968 reverberate in our contemporary politics."

1968 contenders

The two earliest Democrats in the race were Senator Eugene McCarthy of Minnesota and President Lyndon Johnson, who everyone assumed would seek reelection. As the Vietnam War reached a turning point in February 1968 following the Communist Tet Offensive, Senator Robert Kennedy of New York decided to enter the Democratic race. But in March, after President Johnson stunned the country by declaring he would not seek reelection, Vice President Hubert Humphrey decided to run, and Senator George McGovern of South Dakota also joined the race.

Three Republicans, Richard Nixon, Nelson Rockefeller, and Governor Ronald Reagan of California competed for the party's nomination. Nixon and Rockefeller competed early,but Nixon had already won most of the votes necessary to get the nomination. Reagan entered the race late and was viewed as a potential rather than real contender. Former Alabama governor George Wallace, renegade Democrat and ardent segregationist, formed the new Independent Party and pledged to fight for the "forgotten man" against the northern "elites."

Impact of assassinations

Two tragic events occurred in spring 1968 that profoundly affected the mood of the country and the political outlook in an election year. The renowned civil rights leader, Rev. Martin Luther King, was assassinated in Memphis in early April, which triggered massive rioting in many American cities, especially Washington, D.C. where entire blocks in the city's center were gutted by outraged black rioters. Two months later, presidential candidate and brother of the slain president, Robert Kennedy, was gunned down following a political rally in Los Angeles. Suddenly, the political and cultural landscape of the country shifted.  Supporters of King's and Kennedy's views captured the more liberal view of American politics, while other Americans embraced the  conservatives' emphasis on "law and order." Republicans easily nominated Richard Nixon, a staunch conservative, but the Democratic convention in Chicago turned into a bizarre couple of days as anti-Vietnam rioters and leftist groups tried to stop the nomination of Vice President Hubert Humphrey.

Similarities with 2020

The most striking aspect of 1968 and today is the personalities of the two presidents, Lyndon Johnson and Donald Trump. Both are high energy, egocentric, sometimes brutal, leaders determined to force other countries to bend to their will through use of military and economic power. A second similarity is the reality that both men became involved in serious tests of will with two Asian leaders. For Johnson, the enemy was Ho Chi Minh, North Vietnams' Communist leader who aspired to conquer South Vietnam. For Trump, the apparent adversary is China's leader Xi Zinping who refuses to bend to his demands that he change China's damaging trade policies. A major difference from 1968 is that tariffs, not troops, are a new-style economic warfare.

A third similarity with 1968 is that George Wallace exploited growing populist sentiment in the country and threatened the candidacy of Hubert Humphrey. Wallace not only captured southern states but appealed to working class voters in the Midwest. In 2016 Donald Trump tapped into that populist sentiment and added enough states in the mid-West to win the presidency.

The U.S. economy is much stronger in 2019 than it was fifty years ago, and Donald Trump's approval ratings in September this year are somewhat higher than Johnson's were in 1967. But if the economy falters seriously in 2020, Trump may be faced with a similar, although less severe, challenge that Johnson had: "Should I run again?"

File last modified on Sunday, 08-SEP-2019 10:05 AM EST

Feedback to Author